What do you guys think about the female characters in Higurashi
I hated pretty much all of them except Miyo. I thoroughly hated the game, it's like Gogol's Dead Souls in that the only truly good character is [presumed] dead and missing from the story for the duration of it. (I stuck around for 7 chapters because I liked the plot and some of the writing in chapter 3 and had a partial theory about it. At chapter 7 I realized it was a fakeout, there will be no "answers" to chapter 3, it's a big JJ style mystery box.)
The original art is ugly. I upgraded it to the Playstation version.
Rena has a retarded speech quirk and generally acts retarded and/or perverted, and later on the dickbag threatens her with rape or something, and she's like ha ha so hotttt.
"Mion" (the tattooed girl) has ugly balloon tits and acts badass, until she sekritly craves to be a girly girl (all badass girls are sekritly dying to be pampered princesses, don't you know). That's actually a misunderstanding, but the misunderstanding eats up playtime. Then it's revealed that Shion is the badass one, and Mion is a complete nonentity, she doesn't do anything throughout the 7 chapters.
"Shion" is initially badass in her chapter (5) but later she just goes along with her evil family and becomes a nonentity. Her and Mion's family is all evil cunts with horrific parallels to FGM. Satoko's second chapter (7) is stupidly contrived and sadistic on the level of an atheist interpretation of Christianity, Satoko being the bearer of original sin and the evil cunts being a sadistic masturbatory god whose forgiveness she must deserve.
Rika is "really 1000 years old" pedobait and is >implied to have the hots for the actually underage Satoko.
Satoko is initially badass, but is then devolved to pedobait and never gets redeemed. There are multiple opportunities for her to do something in her second chapter (7), speak up on the phone, set a trap, etc, and she's just a passive victim throughout. (She's not evil, she's just a bad character.)
Miyo is at worst neutral, also she's attractive and livens up the story woth her antics. I spotted her back in chapter 1 and rewatched the credits to get her name, which wasn't mentioned in the game. Killing kids is a bad look and you're not supposed to take it in stride (I did tho lol), but the whole place has demon AIDS and is ruled by a child-torturing Yakuza cult. The writer chose to write a contrived, thoroughly plot-holey story with fantastic elements and children deserving of genocide. As a game designer once said, if you write a game in which Jews drink the blood of Christian children, the Holocaust will be a good act within the game world, but it's still repugnant to sit at the table and play the game.
Disclaimer: There are nice-looking female characters in the intro movies. I don't know who they are and I've no opinion on them.
---
As "classic" VN characters go, I nominate Giselle the Maid from
The House in Fata Morgana. The story is terrible and all other characters are terrible (I can rant about it on demand), but Giselle is good, interesting, and deserving of happiness. (The game's a goffick novel and worth playing for the music.)