Anime/Manga - Discuss Japanese cartoons and comics here; NO CULTURE WAR DOOMPOSTING!

  • Twórca wątku Twórca wątku Niachu
  • Data rozpoczęcia Data rozpoczęcia
The MHA fandom didn't ruin MHA. MHA ruined MHA by being a shitty show.
The show was predictable and that was probably it's biggest sin. The moment it was revealed that One for All killed people with quirks I told my friends who were obsessed with the show that Izuku would give up the quirk to beat the big bad.

I was right.

The show/manga has a ton of problems, and if you read it from start to finish you can tell that the author never expected the manga to blow up like it did.
 
The MHA fandom didn't ruin MHA. MHA ruined MHA by being a shitty show.
That series wound up having the biggest last laugh in the end for the sheer fact that all its contemporaries wound up dropping the ball in their respective ends (Jujutsu Kaisen, Chainsaw Man) and the people who hated it being associated with those obsessed with cuckporn due to all the McDonald's meme spam which made people actually saw they were full of shit and re-evaluate it.
 
The show was predictable and that was probably it's biggest sin.
For me the biggest sin was that I either didn't particularly like or outright disliked the vast majority of the cast, especially the "hero" characters. And I hated the setting as well. The story being cookie cutter was a secondary concern for me.

I will say this though: I actually enjoyed reading Vigilantes a lot and the anime for that one is also genuinely good. Having likeable characters and a better setting goes a long way since Vigilantes also has a pretty generic by the numbers story.
 
For me the biggest sin was that I either didn't particularly like or outright disliked the vast majority of the cast, especially the "hero" characters. And I hated the setting as well. The story being cookie cutter was a secondary concern for me.

I will say this though: I actually enjoyed reading Vigilantes a lot and the anime for that one is also genuinely good. Having likeable characters and a better setting goes a long way since Vigilantes also has a pretty generic by the numbers story.
I fucking hated Bakugo and all his fujoshis fans couldn't understand why, when the man is introduced bullying his supposed best friend, tells him to kill himself and threatens to beat the shit out of him regularly
 
I fucking hated Bakugo and all his fujoshis fans couldn't understand why, when the man is introduced bullying his supposed best friend, tells him to kill himself and threatens to beat the shit out of him regularly
Let's not pretend that Deku isn't a little pussybitch faggot who didn't deserve it. Which is the reason I hate Deku. When I say the entire cast I mean most of the entire cast.
 
Let's not pretend that Deku isn't a little pussybitch faggot who didn't deserve it. Which is the reason I hate Deku. When I say the entire cast I mean most of the entire cast.
Oh no I agree. One of the biggest sins for the show that I have always had was that the author didn't let Izuku and Katsuki actually settle their issues properly.

Naruto is shit but Naruto and Sasuke got four fights that settled their rivalry. Izuku and Katsuki got one and a half.

Izuku was also just never allowed to be angry about shit that people did to him. He was selfless to a fault and suicidally heroic, which makes him hard to like.
 
One of the biggest sins for the show that I have always had was that the author didn't let Izuku and Katsuki actually settle their issues properly.
Which is something that the fanbase copes over, they'll seethe over how he he protrayed an abuser as sympathetic but ignore the fact that the guy who told the MC to off himself in the first chapter and bullied as kids doesn't suffer any repercussions for his actions whatsoever just because he's popular.
 
Izuku was also just never allowed to be angry about shit that people did to him. He was selfless to a fault and suicidally heroic, which makes him hard to like.
One of the biggest issues that I have with MHA is that it's trying really hard to emulate classic western superhero comics but it's made by a guy who doesn't really seem to understand them very well. Deku is probably the prime example of that along with the setting.
 
One of the biggest issues that I have with MHA is that it's trying really hard to emulate classic western superhero comics but it's made by a guy who doesn't really seem to understand them very well. Deku is probably the prime example of that along with the setting.
I think he wanted Izuku to be like Peter Parker while ignoring or not understanding what makes Peter and Spider-Man so compelling.

The super hero as a job thing doesn't help, there's a reason people liked Vigilante more, secret identities and the alternate personality of the hero compared to the civilian life are key parts of the heros mythos.

Clark Kent and Superman are very different from each other.

Spider-Man is confident where Peter is a dork, so on.

Meanwhile Izuku and Deku are the same bitchy person
 
I guess they dropped a preview for the new episode of that loser catgirl anime




Born too late to explore the Earth.
Born too early to explore the stars.
Born just in time to see a catgirl do heroin.

7138.jpg
 
The super hero as a job thing doesn't help, there's a reason people liked Vigilante more, secret identities and the alternate personality of the hero compared to the civilian life are key parts of the heros mythos.
The other thing is that Marvel and to a lesser extent DC have already done the whole "Supers need to be regulated and licensed for the good of society" thing. It was called Marvel: Civil War, and it also serves as one of the key ideological debates underpinning the entire X-Men franchise of personal privacy and liberty vs authoritarian security measures.
 
The new GITS looks great and while previous iterations were not completely without humor, this adaption features a lot of the sort of black comedy of the original.

Also:
APnFc.jpg
 
Wstecz
Top Na dole