💬 Off-Topic Critical Discussion of Trannies and Pedophilia

[SourDiesel]

I realize this probably over-simplifies the issue but I'm genuinely curious what you guys think, because my brain still just can't get around it. Maybe I'm getting old, I don't know.

But, like, y'all remember Rachel Dolezal? That crazy white chick that went 'viral' a while back because she "identifies as a black woman." She had nothing but European white-girl genes, but through some serious tanning and strategically-styled hair, she created the illusion of blackness, and was even the president of her local chapter of the NAACP...until it came out that she was white, and her bullshit "B-but I feel black!" logic was summarily smacked down by both bigots and SJWs alike, regardless of race. She was promptly relieved of her post, heavily criticized, generally agreed upon as totally nuts, and promptly forgotten by society. As it should be.

So how is this any different? How is this man's lying in return for social capital and access to female society + bodies any different than Dolezal's lying for career capital and access to black society? Why was her false entitlement to black culture so reprehensible, but the trans community is generally lauded and supported for doing, as far as I can tell, exactly the same thing - just to a different protected class?

I'm not trying to be a shithead here, either, or REEEEE that trans people don't exist/should die/don't deserve rights/whatever. I'm genuinely curious to hear what you guys think because while I agree that legally, nobody can stop somebody like Dolezal from basically cosplaying blackness on a daily basis, it seems to be clear to most that Ms. Dolezal and others like her have no right to divert laws, career positions, or social programs intended for black people for their own personal gain. However this collective social consensus seemingly evaporates when you replace "black people" with "women." Exhibit A: the namesake of this subforum. You couldn't find a more blatant example of a woman-hating creep using the current culture of transphilia (there's a term you never hear, eh?) to his advantage to gain access to women for nefarious purposes if you tried. I mean, right? Am I nuts? Like, clearly whatever safeguards are in place to protect the black community from people like Dolezal should be implemented here to protect women from people like Yaniv, right?

I'm just mindfucked by this. And I can only discuss it with a few select people IRL who won't knee-jerk react and freak out because transphobia is murder now, or something. It's kinda sad. Intelligent, educated folks - often "cis" women themselves - who I've know for years will look at me like I'm Literally Hitler if I say what I said here, even if I take care to word it very delicately, so as not to offend any sensitive feels. I'm a pretty open-minded, easy-going person, politics-wise, but it's crazy to me that any time I've brought anything like this up IRL, it feels like I've committed a thought crime.

I don't know, man. Educate me, wise Kiwis. What gives?

You have nothing to learn, you seem to understand the situation entirely. When Dolezal was a thing lots of people made exactly the argument you're making now. Some were black some were white, some were some other race or ethnicity but all were tarred as transphobic bigots. It's different apparently because reasons. No they will not elaborate you fucking TERF.

@AbraCadaver is right though too (no idea why my user tags aren't working rn, sorry). Trannies are actually higher on the progressive stack than black women believe it or not. The whole "cis women are mean to trans women" thing. So trannies won that argument. You're totally not wrong to notice this inconsistency though.

 

[Munchma Quchi]

Through shitposts, to the stars

To the sweat rolls down my balls

 

[tuscangarder]

You have nothing to learn, you seem to understand the situation entirely. When Dolezal was a thing lots of people made exactly the argument you're making now. Some were black some were white, some were some other race or ethnicity but all were tarred as transphobic bigots. It's different apparently because reasons. No they will not elaborate you fucking TERF.

@AbraCadaver is right though too (no idea why my user tags aren't working rn, sorry). Trannies are actually higher on the progressive stack than black women believe it or not. The whole "cis women are mean to trans women" thing. So trannies won that argument. You're totally not wrong to notice this inconsistency though.

The argument was that sex is biological by nature and race is mostly social. Basically, you can't transition to something that doesn't really exist or is created by society. It was a trans-medical argument, born in the wrong body.. This was before the non-binary people took over the trans-movement, I think.

 

[Death Grip]

You have to look at it in terms of the oppression card game that it is. The more impressive your stack of oppressions, the more you win.

Dolezal is a white woman going up against black culture. She loses because “black people” is a better card than “white woman”, since it’s more oppressed. Yaniv is a transgender person going up against women. Even someone with a hand of “immigrant and woman” loses against his hand of “woman and trans” because trans is higher up on the oppression scale in Canada than either woman or immigrant.

It’s all a goddamn card game and if you get a full house of minority, trans, disabled, gay and deathfat, you get to win every argument for the rest of time.

Common sense has no place in this game. (Tbf I agree Rachel was a horrid person and should not pretend to be black. But you and I have sense that doesn’t work here.)

I really must get round to designing that Oppression Top Trump's pack that is sitting at the back of my brain.
Also I self identify as a billionaire so please respect the fact I have pretty much unlimited funds in my bank account.

 

[SourDiesel]

The argument was that sex is biological by nature and race is mostly social. Basically, you can't transition to something that doesn't really exist or is created by society. It was a trans-medical argument, born in the wrong body.. This was before the non-binary people took over the trans-movement, I think.

I heard that one but tbh few people on that train. Obviously most didn't want to associate with biology. I heard a lot of stupid excuses. Non binary was definitely a thing then. If I had to pick one excuse that I thought was most common it would be the one where "a million gender doctors can't be wrong". Trans women are real because doctors say so but no doctors say you can change race. It's that classic thing where they've fired and replaced all the professionals with asspatters and then point at the newly installed "professional asspatters" as proof that professionals agree with them.

Edit: this is such a big thing tbh and it bothers me everytime I hear some reasonable person come to a reasonable conclusion about this shit and wonder why no one has studied this while not realizing that many people did. There are scores of pages of research on troons by people who dedicated thier entire lives to the subject but all of it has been memoryholed and those researchers have all been fired for troonphobia.

 

[Bi Eraser]

Honestly my pet theory on the connection with trans people and fucking children is that a trans person get raped and/or sexually assaulted at a young age which is a pretty heavy trauma which from what I can remember can cause you to become almost "stuck" in that time during the trauma took place as the sheer mental toll it takes on you causes you to never really fully shelf that part of your life. The thing with the troons is they're still stuck in that place, which has retarded their growth and caused them to still kind of act like how they were back when they were still a kid. So they're basically fucking children because they've been traumatised to such a extent that they've not advanced into true adulthood and are still stuck in some facet of their childhood because they've been raped/assualted.

Honestly I don't think it's too far fetched because of the absolute massive amount of sexual assault trans people face, with a lot of the FTMs I've met being sexually assaulted at a young age (which can also explain them being FTM to an extent, as a coping mechanism) and I think something like 50% or so of the trans community facing some form of sexual assault.

 

[SourDiesel]

Honestly my pet theory on the connection with trans people and fucking children is that a trans person get raped and/or sexually assaulted at a young age which is a pretty heavy trauma which from what I can remember can cause you to become almost "stuck" in that time during the trauma took place as the sheer mental toll it takes on you causes you to never really fully shelf that part of your life. The thing with the troons is they're still stuck in that place, which has exceptional their growth and caused them to still kind of act like how they were back when they were still a kid. So they're basically fucking children because they've been traumatised to such a extent that they've not advanced into true adulthood and are still stuck in some facet of their childhood because they've been raped/assualted.

Honestly I don't think it's too far fetched because of the absolute massive amount of sexual assault trans people face, with a lot of the FTMs I've met being sexually assaulted at a young age (which can also explain them being FTM to an extent, as a coping mechanism) and I think something like 50% or so of the trans community facing some form of sexual assault.

Alternatively, it's possible they all have personality disorders and some personality disorders are caused by childhood trauma. A lot of ftms I see the sexual assault connection because a lot of them tell stories about thier transition that betray the truth. Mtfs on the other hand are mostly paraphilic narcissists.

But it's the mtfs who are fucking kids, not the ftms as far as I've seen so I'm not sure it's the sexual abuse that causes the pedophilia as much as the raging cluster b energy.

 

[BlueCoal]

Sexual offender to live in Edmonton, police issue warning

Police have issued a warning about a sexual offender who has been released from prison and will be living in the Edmonton area.

edmonton.ctvnews.ca

Canada seems to be pumping out middle aged transexual pedophile convicts. Heres another one using their female image to access children.

Not even surprised anymore.

I forgot theres a group thats classic for deflecting their bad eggs' actions other than troons in Canada and it's Natives. If it wasn't for settlers 200 years ago this man born in the 70s wouldnt be a kid diddler. Getting yourself into a healing lodge is pretty much a get out of jail free card too.

 

[OjSimpsonFan21]

I personally fall on the transmedicalist side of the argument, and if we go based on that what I find odd is these people transitioning at a much later age. I figure if you have dysphoria you want to gtfo of their body like ASAP, so it kinda raises some red flags to me that these people don’t “figure out they are trans” until 30-40.

I also really don’t appreciate the current narrative that I see being pushed in some cases that everyone that doesn’t fit into traditional gender roles is suddenly trans.

 

[the xerx]

I realize this probably over-simplifies the issue but I'm genuinely curious what you guys think, because my brain still just can't get around it. Maybe I'm getting old, I don't know.

But, like, y'all remember Rachel Dolezal? That crazy white chick that went 'viral' a while back because she "identifies as a black woman." She had nothing but European white-girl genes, but through some serious tanning and strategically-styled hair, she created the illusion of blackness, and was even the president of her local chapter of the NAACP...until it came out that she was white, and her bullshit "B-but I feel black!" logic was summarily smacked down by both bigots and SJWs alike, regardless of race. She was promptly relieved of her post, heavily criticized, generally agreed upon as totally nuts, and promptly forgotten by society. As it should be.

So how is this any different? How is this man's lying in return for social capital and access to female society + bodies any different than Dolezal's lying for career capital and access to black society? Why was her false entitlement to black culture so reprehensible, but the trans community is generally lauded and supported for doing, as far as I can tell, exactly the same thing - just to a different protected class?

I'm not trying to be a shithead here, either, or REEEEE that trans people don't exist/should die/don't deserve rights/whatever. I'm genuinely curious to hear what you guys think because while I agree that legally, nobody can stop somebody like Dolezal from basically cosplaying blackness on a daily basis, it seems to be clear to most that Ms. Dolezal and others like her have no right to divert laws, career positions, or social programs intended for black people for their own personal gain. However this collective social consensus seemingly evaporates when you replace "black people" with "women." Exhibit A: the namesake of this subforum. You couldn't find a more blatant example of a woman-hating creep using the current culture of transphilia (there's a term you never hear, eh?) to his advantage to gain access to women for nefarious purposes if you tried. I mean, right? Am I nuts? Like, clearly whatever safeguards are in place to protect the black community from people like Dolezal should be implemented here to protect women from people like Yaniv, right?

I'm just mindfucked by this. And I can only discuss it with a few select people IRL who won't knee-jerk react and freak out because transphobia is murder now, or something. It's kinda sad. Intelligent, educated folks - often "cis" women themselves - who I've know for years will look at me like I'm Literally Hitler if I say what I said here, even if I take care to word it very delicately, so as not to offend any sensitive feels. I'm a pretty open-minded, easy-going person, politics-wise, but it's crazy to me that any time I've brought anything like this up IRL, it feels like I've committed a thought crime.

I don't know, man. Educate me, wise Kiwis. What gives?

Parts of the Dolezal-JY analogy don't fit though. Despite claims to the contrary, JY isn't in any kind of leadership position the way Dolezal was. Also all that happened with Dolezal was she got negative media attention and had to give up her position. JY has had negative media already, and has no position to give up. While the trans community probably has more crazies, I do think that they'd expel someone like JY from any position of power if he was exposed for the type of shit JY does.

 

[SourDiesel]

I do think that they'd expel someone like JY from any position of power if he was exposed for the type of shit JY does.

IF he was exposed. But only if he was exposed and it started causing them problems. They have absolutely no problem with the type of shit Yaniv does in general. Morgane Oger supported him for a long time until it became obviously political suicide and he couldn't ignore it anymore.

Oger is an odious slimy bastard but does hold some position of power. Oger is responsible for the eleven year court battle against Vancouver Rape Relief because they didn't hire some tranny to be a women's rape crisis counselor. Then he had thier city funding pulled. Speaking of odious slimes being protected by the trans community, have you ever heard of trans lifeline? Not to mention all the Rhys McKinnons of the world that take women's rightful places on sports podiums. None of these people have been expelled from anything.

 

[Random_Numbers140097]

Sexual offender to live in Edmonton, police issue warning

Police have issued a warning about a sexual offender who has been released from prison and will be living in the Edmonton area.

edmonton.ctvnews.ca

Canada seems to be pumping out middle aged transexual pedophile convicts. Heres another one using their female image to access children.

Holy Jesus, that one made child pornography featuring children three and under. Why is he allowed out of prison?

 

[OttoWest]

Holy Jesus, that one made child pornography featuring children three and under. Why is he allowed out of prison?

I wonder if they’ll revoke his release like they did with Matthew Harks.

 

[pr3nt177]

Sexual offender to live in Edmonton, police issue warning

Police have issued a warning about a sexual offender who has been released from prison and will be living in the Edmonton area.

edmonton.ctvnews.ca

Canada seems to be pumping out middle aged transexual pedophile convicts. Heres another one using their female image to access children.

Not even surprised anymore.

I forgot theres a group thats classic for deflecting their bad eggs' actions other than troons in Canada and it's Natives. If it wasn't for settlers 200 years ago this man born in the 70s wouldnt be a kid diddler. Getting yourself into a healing lodge is pretty much a get out of jail free card too.

"The Edmonton Police Service says they have grounds to believe Laverne Waskahat, 42, is of significant harm to the community and will commit another sexual offence against a child under the age of 16 while in the community."

Absolutely disgusting. It's obvious from the article that this nonce can't control himself yet he's been released. I wouldn't bat an eyelid if people like this were banged up till their last breath. Better still, find an island, dump all the nonces there then nuke them all.

 

[AnOminous]

"The Edmonton Police Service says they have grounds to believe Laverne Waskahat, 42, is of significant harm to the community and will commit another sexual offence against a child under the age of 16 while in the community."

"Hey we got this pedo and we're pretty sure he's gonna go around raping people cause he's just that kind of guy. We're just gonna let him go though. Good luck!"

 

[RE 374]

"The Edmonton Police Service says they have grounds to believe Laverne Waskahat, 42, is of significant harm to the community and will commit another sexual offence against a child under the age of 16 while in the community."

Absolutely disgusting. It's obvious from the article that this nonce can't control himself yet he's been released. I wouldn't bat an eyelid if people like this were banged up till their last breath. Better still, find an island, dump all the nonces there then nuke them all.

But this stunning and brave woman is trans and Native, that's even more oppressed than black and trans. Surely we must treat this individual with kid gloves lest Canada be viewed as not woke.

Send him out of the city to the sticks or near a reserve. Either hicks with guns or Rez Justice are just nature taking its course.

 

[SourDiesel]

But this stunning and brave woman is trans and Native, that's even more oppressed than black and trans. Surely we must treat this individual with kid gloves lest Canada be viewed as not woke.

Send him out of the city to the sticks or near a reserve. Either hicks with guns or Rez Justice are just nature taking its course.

Come on, you know Canada is performatively and selectively woke just like everywhere else. Sure, people in Canada seem to love trannies but they absolutely hate native people. It's hard to say if these two things cancel each other out but he's certainly not going to get more love than a black tranny. This one might be back in prison before you know it. Better if he was white.

 

[Crab]

I'm a lesbian so I frequent a few LGBT spaces both offline and online, and I have observations from the (steadily increasing) trans population.

Autism. Very high level of it. They vastly outnumber the trans women that either don't have autism or haven't said they have it yet. I find this very interesting.

Extremely high levels of narcissism, utterly obsessed with themselves and will steer any conversation to be about themselves whenever possible, which is exhausting when you've got multiple trans women doing it constantly.
They tend to overwhelm a space, make it all about being trans, and hound out the LGB people with a combination of never shutting up about being trans and forcing everyone else to feel like they're constantly walking on eggshells because anything perceived as negative that you say to a trans woman is immediately an attack and you've ACTIVATED THEIR DYSPHORIA and you are harassed out. As a cis woman you are not allowed to talk about cis woman things because that causes dysphoria to them, you must stay quiet and never talk about anything biological goin on with yourself.

This is the thing that bothers me most - they're so infantile. They only seem to know how to act like stupid little girls, and they think it's cute. It's not, it's weird. They seem overwhelmingly fans of little anime girls which seems an odd coincidence.

This isn't a constructive post I'm just ranting I guess about how every queer space I'm in is being gentrified by trans women and I'm tired and cranky about it.

edit: also I forgot, tons are obsessed with having huge tits and making polycules, y'know like how cis women aren't/don't. BIG TITTIE MAKE ME BIG MORE WOMAN it's not a fetish!!

 

[Patricia Highsmith]

Honestly my pet theory on the connection with trans people and fucking children is that a trans person get raped and/or sexually assaulted at a young age which is a pretty heavy trauma which from what I can remember can cause you to become almost "stuck" in that time during the trauma took place as the sheer mental toll it takes on you causes you to never really fully shelf that part of your life. The thing with the troons is they're still stuck in that place, which has exceptional their growth and caused them to still kind of act like how they were back when they were still a kid. So they're basically fucking children because they've been traumatised to such a extent that they've not advanced into true adulthood and are still stuck in some facet of their childhood because they've been raped/assualted.

Honestly I don't think it's too far fetched because of the absolute massive amount of sexual assault trans people face, with a lot of the FTMs I've met being sexually assaulted at a young age (which can also explain them being FTM to an extent, as a coping mechanism) and I think something like 50% or so of the trans community facing some form of sexual assault.

This doesn't explain the avalanche of 60 + year old white men, married with children, professional, intelligent, successful, educated, tenured, famous, wealthy, men who suddenly realize they are in the wrong body. What's their fucking excuse? These embalmed cosmetic surgery fetishists, taking the piss out of their indulgent workplace, and humiliating their long suffering wife who goes along with it, it's bizarre.

 

[RibbedCondominium]

Always use her proper pronouns. It stops LGBT lurkers from having an excuse to "click off in disgust" and forces the "LGBT community" to acknowledge this obvious fake potential molester as one of theirs.

Hate how trans are a protected class? You can help undo that by elevating people like Yaniv.

Yes, by elevating JY and, in turn, backing the activist end of the LGBTQ community into a corner of its own design. This is where memes come in handy, as they can get right to the heart of hypocrisy and/or double standards.