TED Entertainment Inc. v. Alexandra Marwa Saber, Morgan Kamal Majed, and Kasey Caviness, California 2:25-cv-5564, 2:25-cv-5565,Missouri 4:25-cv-459 - Ethan Klein Suing three women and 10 redditors for Copyright Infringement.

[D_Tractor]

I just realized that Ethan loosing will inspire a shitload of more people to do low effort slop "reaction" videos that were super popular on youtube about a decade ago before the original creators cracked down on copyright enforcement.

 

[AnOminous]

I'm the nigger of the entire world

What do you expect from a Biden appointee?

At least there's new copyright law to be enjoyed, completely ignoring decades of previously existing law. Welcome to freedom.

I just realized that Ethan loosing will inspire a shitload of more people to do low effort slop "reaction" videos that were super popular on youtube about a decade ago before the original creators cracked down on copyright enforcement.

Ethan losing will be a consolation prize. Still, he should roll the dice on a Ninth Circuit appeal, because this particular decision very well may piss off a lot of Hollywood.

 

[Lego Man]

I just realized that Ethan loosing will inspire a shitload of more people to do low effort slop "reaction" videos that were super popular on youtube about a decade ago before the original creators cracked down on copyright enforcement.

Low effort reactions were already incentivized before the H3 lawsuits. You would think an effort to correct behavior in reacting to videos would be effective, but it turned out to be futile. It was frowned upon, almost sort of like an unwritten rule of YouTube creators.

 

[SoyBoyCaliphate]

I just realized that Ethan loosing will inspire a shitload of more people to do low effort slop "reaction" videos that were super popular on youtube about a decade ago before the original creators cracked down on copyright enforcement.

I mean he actually already set the precedent that led to this type of content to be considered fair use, like a decade ago. In fact that specific lawsuit is mentioned in this ruling. I don't see how this ruling would lead to more reaction slop, since it's already everywhere, and I don't think anyone thought it was illegal (except maybe for eurpoors)

 

[AnOminous]

I just realized that Ethan loosing will inspire a shitload of more people to do low effort slop "reaction" videos that were super popular on youtube about a decade ago before the original creators cracked down on copyright enforcement.

Just steal a screener DVD meant for critics and put it on YouTube the day the movie comes out. Grunt unintelligibly every 20 minutes or so. Maybe just say "this sucks." That's now "fair use."

 

[LOWERCASE LETTERS]

This is not some slam dunk against ethan, it's just the judge telling his lawyer "tighten up your pleadings you retard".

 

[TrainWreckWatcher]

I want them all to lose so I can keep winning.

 

[AnOminous]

I want them all to lose so I can keep winning.

If all this means is copyright takes a haircut, and we can all just air anything anyone streams and laugh at it, I would put up with a kikewin.

I still want to see redditors suck dicks. And by "see" I don't actually mean see these fat fucking cunts suck 2 inch penises, I just want to see them lose.

If the Jew loses, despite the actual law this Biden-appointed cocksucking faggot just made up, whatever. Let him take it to the Ninth, roll the dice, see what happens. He could easily win there because look how gay this decision is.

 

[frari]

I first thought it was a slam dunk for Ethan after seeing the clips of Denims saying "don't give Ethan money and watch his stream here".

Then I saw the timeline Denims had in her response showing the pauses during her playback of Ethans stream, then I had doubts about Ethan winning.


I guess at the end of the day it may be a win for free use. Which we should all be happy for, even if it's a win for a vapid ewhore thot like Denims.
Kaceytron gotta be feeling like a retard for settling right about now. Wonder what Frogan will do.

 

[Fields Of Rye]

Well, I’m honestly pretty clouded by my hatred for most reaction YouTubers. I have a hard time as a concept seeing streaming simultaneous to the premier release itself as a fair use - I know my notion is not the technical meaning of fair though. But, whatever, ultimately I can’t say i really care one way or another - no one here is particularly likeable, it’s just different shades and degrees of unlikable

I think the copywrite system is gay and retarded too but this is frankly one of those issues where the bad law not being applied equally and fairly makes the bad law worse.

If you did this with a disney movie the lawyers would get to rape you. Every fucking gun on the planet would turn and obliterate your ass from existence. You would die like a hamster in all conceivable realities; and as the sum of all your parts moved as one to the next trichiliocosm, a great shadow in the shape of a mouse on the Trisāhasramahāsāhasra. would stuff your soul into one of those sea cucumbers whose anus shoots out whenever it's scared. That's how raped you would get. Prolapse-SeaCucumber-Gigaraped.

Something like half of the Mystery Science theatre movies are still locked down because in a not-to-distant-future they still fear the Thousand-Millionfold-Assrape Trisa-hamster-whatever that word was. But that's because the judge knows if she tried to step to Disney or Warner she'd be ejecting sea cucumber anuses with the rest of us.

Do I care for the fate of Lex Jewthor and his Savage Snifflers? Not really. But would it be funny to watch the last crumbs of breadtube get put through whatever the fuck I typed two paragraphs ago? Absolutely. Ergo I am sad.

 

[AnOminous]

I love that this decision by this slant-eyed freak means that everyone everywhere can just openly pirate anything Hollywood comes out with by just repeating it in its entirety while some whore mumbles gibberish every few minutes, after having advertised you'd get to watch the entire movie.

This slanty-eyed chink should be sent back to China or. . .I dunno, just somewhere other than here. It's hard to view this gook as any kind of human.

 

[Radola Gajda]

Low effort reactions were already incentivized before the H3 lawsuits. You would think an effort to correct behavior in reacting to videos would be effective, but it turned out to be futile. It was frowned upon, almost sort of like an unwritten rule of YouTube creators.

Yeah , because YouTube today is not filled with lowest of the low effort.
Check this out. (stolen AI generated short plays in its entirety).
This lolsuit will have (almost) no effect on YouTube ecosystem. YouTubers don't need encouragment to be as lazy as possible.

 

[frari]

If you did this with a disney movie the lawyers would get to rape you.

That was one of my first thoughts when I read this. If the case is dismissed on fair-use grounds, could that then serve as further precedent for others attempting something similar with a TV show or movie?

My gut says no because money. but it will be interesting to see it tested.

 

[SoyBoyCaliphate]

I love that this decision by this slant-eyed freak means that everyone everywhere can just openly pirate anything Hollywood comes out with by just repeating it in its entirety while some whore mumbles gibberish every few minutes, after having advertised you'd get to watch the entire movie.

This slanty-eyed chink should be sent back to China or. . .I dunno, just somewhere other than here. It's hard to view this gook as any kind of human.

That's just not what the lawsuit says, at all. Ethan self owned over and over, and basically stated in the lawsuit that Denim was *transforming* his content into something else due to the commentary she added. Her audience was clearly not there just to watch the Nule either. They were there for her criticism and her take on his video. Again, if they wanted to watch his content nuke, they could have just watched it on his channel or from any reupload

Everyone making comparisons with disney movies or ripping an NFL game simply missed most of the ruling. If you watch someone's stream to see his take on football game, play by play, that's completely different from just watching someone say a few words here and there which would actually provide a substitute for the real NFL game. Look at the timeline of the stream too. No one was watching 2h of additional Denim's commentary just to watch the content nuke. At some point if you want to criticize an entire video, you have to play the entire video. Idk how 2h of commentary (not breaks) is not enough for a 1h40min video.


And again, why did he not just take down her video with a dmca claim? Youtube's system is stricter than the law itself. He tried to use copyright to go after people he hates and he failed.

But also, his lawyer is an actual fucking retard lol. Like wow.

 

[Trigger Me Timbers]

Some excerpts. Pretty damning for Ethan.

Factor 1: Purpose and character of the use
a) Transformative nature
Wyświetl załącznik 9102420
Wyświetl załącznik 9102425
Wyświetl załącznik 9102523

Wyświetl załącznik 9102426
Wyświetl załącznik 9102428
Wyświetl załącznik 9102433

b) Commercial use
Wyświetl załącznik 9102435

Factor 2: Nature of the copyrighted work
Wyświetl załącznik 9102437
Wyświetl załącznik 9102485
Wyświetl załącznik 9102496
Wyświetl załącznik 9102492

Factor 3: Amount and substantiality of the portion in relation to the whole
Wyświetl załącznik 9102453
Wyświetl załącznik 9102456

Factor 4: Effect of the use on the potential market
Wyświetl załącznik 9102459
Wyświetl załącznik 9102461
Wyświetl załącznik 9102463
Wyświetl załącznik 9102464

Conclusion
Wyświetl załącznik 9102550
Wyświetl załącznik 9102551

W Denims

So wait, Demins wins (ie. doesn't have to give Lex Jewther any of her Sheckles) but Frogan-the-hutt will have to give him money?

Sides status: ORBIT

 

[Stupid Sexy Flanders]

So, by arguing that she's using his content to produce anti-semitic content, he basically agreed that it's transformative?

 

[lolwatagain]

If all this means is copyright takes a haircut, and we can all just air anything anyone streams and laugh at it, I would put up with a kikewin.

I still want to see redditors suck dicks. And by "see" I don't actually mean see these fat fucking cunts suck 2 inch penises, I just want to see them lose.

If the Jew loses, despite the actual law this Biden-appointed cocksucking faggot just made up, whatever. Let him take it to the Ninth, roll the dice, see what happens. He could easily win there because look how gay this decision is.

I first thought it was a slam dunk for Ethan after seeing the clips of Denims saying "don't give Ethan money and watch his stream here".

Then I saw the timeline Denims had in her response showing the pauses during her playback of Ethans stream, then I had doubts about Ethan winning.
Wyświetl załącznik 9102892

I guess at the end of the day it may be a win for free use. Which we should all be happy for, even if it's a win for a vapid ewhore thot like Denims.
Kaceytron gotta be feeling like a retard for settling right about now. Wonder what Frogan will do.

One thing I'm not particularly fond of with the tentative is that it does not analyze how much of the "commentary" is incidental or relevant to the underlying work. Even in the tentative itself, I'm not certain how the fuck "(3) stating that disabled Americans lose disability benefits when they get married;(4) incarceration levels in the United States" relates in any way to "criticism of Piker’s apologia of China’s genocide of the Uyghurs." Disability benefits and incarceration levels in the US seems like a hell of a non-sequitur when it comes to commenting on the Turkroach deepthroating China for killing Uyghurs.

 

[Canard]

Actually if this ended up screwing all copyright over when you stream and pause enough times it would be extremely funny in itself. Get fucked all of media.

 

[The President of Nintendo]

I guess at the end of the day it may be a win for free use. Which we should all be happy for, even if it's a win for a vapid ewhore thot like Denims.

Holy Freudian slip Batman!

The only favorable outcome in this scenario is if everyone involved gathers in the courthouse and gets obliterated by an asteroid strike.

Reddit snarkers and the insufferable internet personalities they obsess over are just two halves of a gay ouroboros - instead of being a snake devouring its own tail its two faggots 69ing each other's dicks.

 

[TrainWreckWatcher]

Wonder what Frogan will do.

As dumb as Kacetron may look. She is a million times better off than Frogan by giving that statement and ending it. Frogan defaulted. Her fat muslim ass is fucked.